Orange County Grand Jury • 2008-2009 • Agency Response
Response to: "Paper Water" - Does Orange County Have A Reliable Future? 06/19/09 4.13MB

City of LOS Alamitos October 5, 2009 The Honorable Kim Dunning Presiding Judge of the Superior Court*

Published: October 05, 2009 4 pages
View Original PDF

Note: Missing finding numbers detected: F3

Findings and Recommendations 3 findings

F1
There is inadequate coordination between local land-use planning agencies and local water supply agencies, resulting in a process that fails to fully engage the issues. الربع أبالأرأ المراكب المالية المائيان (a): Water agencies have tended to avoid interfering with or participating in growth-management decisions. (b). Cities and the County have tended to not critically evaluate the limitations of the water agencies' supply projections. The City of Los Alamitos takes seriously its commitment to coordinating land use decision with the local purveyor but stops short on rendering a decision regarding the entire industry. The City of Los Alamitos is a built out community that is served by a single water purveyor, Golden State- Water. Most of the development in the recent years has been well below the 500 dwelling unit threshold. In addition, all development is subject to the requirements of California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) with The CEQA checklist specifically extensive infrastructure analysis. includes a "Utilities and Service Systems" section related to availability of 3191 Katelia Avenue Los Alamitos, CA sufficient water supplies to serve the project from existing entitlements, 90720-5600 and whether or not the construction of new water or wastewater treatment Telephone: facilities, or expansion of existing facilities could cause significant (562) 431-3538 environmental effects. The Planning Division relies on water purveyor FAX (562) 493-1255 expertise and works closely with regional and local water agencies to www.ci.Los-Alamitos.ca.us ensure that this requirement can be met. . 7 . 2 °C 31 The state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of the state of t egin again a sinesa In addition, the potential impact of other reasonable water conservation measures (e.g. structured pricing rates, mandatory rationing) would have Grand Jury Response - Paper Water Report much greater impact and effectiveness in controlling limited water resources in comparison to potential limitations on new development. These measures would also be more effective in raising public consciousness of water supply as an issue.
Related Recommendations (1)
R1
Each Orange County municipal planning agency, in cooperation with its respective water supply agency, should prepare for adoption by its city council, a dedicated Water Element to its General Plan in conjunction with a future update, not to exceed June 30, 2010. This document should include detailed implementation measures based on objective-based policies that match realistic projections of the County's future water supplies. These objectives, policies and implementation measures should address imported supply constraints, including catastrophic outages and incorporate the realistic availability and timing of "new" water sources such as desalination, contaminated groundwater reclamation and surface water recycling. Each local jurisdiction is required by state law to include seven elements in their local General Plan. As a Charter City, we adhere to the state . . . . . standard and add additional elements as deemed necessary to address specific issues related to our jurisdiction. This recommendation exceeds the state law requirements for General Plans. In lieu of a suggested new Element in the General Plan the City of Los Alamitos has addressed water conservation and policy concerns in the following ways: Policies related to water resources, supplies and conservation are already included in the "Conservation Element." To further enforce conservation, the City of Los Alamitos will soon consider a new Water Conservation Ordinance proposed by the Metropolitan Water District of Orange County (MWDOC), as well as the proposed Landscape Ordinance suggested by MWDOC upon the finalization of their recommendation. Grand Jury Response - Paper Water Report Pursuant to state law, Golden State Water conducts analysis for water supply and availability for new development and significant redevelopment. Adding a new General Plan Element would duplicate processes that are already in place. There are new state mandates for landscape water conservation • that would address water consumption for exterior uses and related to existing and new development. The City of Los Alamitos will either adopt state mandates or local requirements that would include significant water saving measures related to landscape material selection and irrigation systems. The development of a General Plan Element would take at least two years, including the preparation of supplemental_Environmental Impact Report (EIR). The City budget for this fiscal year has already been adopted, and the associated cost for environmental consulting services could range from $50,000 to $75,000. The cost for preparing an optional Water Element that is not required by state law would be significant. Given the minimal potential for net effectiveness and the City fiscal concerns, the preparation of an optional Water Element is not supported. The City appreciates the opportunity to comment on the grand jury report. If you have any questions/comments, please contact Steven Mendoza, Community Development Director at (562) 431-3538, extension 300. Sincerely, CITY OF LOS ALAMITOS Troy D. Edgar Mayor James R. Pérez, Foreman CC:
F2
California's looming water supply crisis receives very little, if any, expressed concern from the public in comparison to the numerous other environmental issues presented during development project reviews. (a). Orange County's citizens and interest groups do not appear to grasp the seriousness of the water supply situation or the complexity and urgency of the necessary solutions. (b). Several recent, substantial water supply awareness efforts are underway (e.g. the O.C. Water Summit) that show promise but appear targeted to audiences that are already informed. The City of Los Alamitos continues to enforce its adopted Water Conservation Ordinance and has worked in tandem with the City's water purveyor to inform the public. In recent years, the water industry has collectively advertised itself as the "Family of Southern California Water Agencies" and promoted "Bewaterwise.com" to disseminate the information and provide water conservation tips and opportunities. Retail agencies utilize bill stuffers, newsletters and websites to inform the public and there are several programs available to K-6 students and their families. F.3: LAFCO is the agency charged with facilitation constructive changes in governmental structure to promote efficient delivery of services. To this end, LAFCO is conducting a governance study of MWDOC which is the designated representative for nearly all of the Orange County retail water agencies, acting on their behalf with their surface water supplier Metropolitan. (a). There are a number of points of governance disagreement between MWDOC and several of its member agencies. This is creating an impediment to the on-going effectiveness of these agencies in critical areas of Orange County's water supply management. (b). The current disagreement is a distraction from the greater good of the agencies working toward Orange County's water future. (c). The stakeholders in LAFCO's study failed to meet their March 11, 2009 deadline for LAFCO's public hearing on this matter. Continued delays are unacceptable. The City of Los Alamitos will continue to work with LAFCO regarding these issues. 7 4 Grand Jury Response – Paper Water Report
No recommendations for this finding
F4
Orange County is uniquely fortunate to have a vast, high-quality, well- managed groundwater basin serving its north geographical area. However, in its south reaches, it has an equally large, high-growth area with virtually no available groundwater resources. (a). The difference in groundwater availability creates a "haves versus have-nots" situation that is conducive to inherent conflicts. (b). The difference in groundwater availability provides opportunities for responsible participants to develop and construct long-term solutions which will benefit the entire County. Water availability for development is through the regional water supplier and not dependent only on local water supplies. Use of storage in the Orange County Water District (OCWD) basin is allowed by agreement with OCWD. This program is also currently being used to allow exchange of water to south Orange County during emergency situations. Grand Jury's Recommendation and City's Response:
No recommendations for this finding

* This report's PDF did not contain easily extractable text and required Optical Character Recognition (OCR) for analysis. There may be minor errors in the extracted findings and recommendations due to OCR limitations with scanned documents.