Riverside County Grand Jury
• 2010-2011
Cooperative Extension Riverside County - Blythe
⚠️ Translation Notice: This content has been automatically translated. The original English text is the official version. Translation may contain errors.
⚠️ Este contenido ha sido traducido automáticamente. El texto original en inglés es la versión oficial. La traducción puede contener errores.
Findings and Recommendations 6 findings
F1
Improper Storage of Toxic Chemicals with Flammable Chemicals A variety of flammable and toxic chemicals used in the lab are stored in a flame resistant (color coded yellow) metal cabinet in the workroom located in Cooperative Extension Department, but not all chemicals are stored in this cabinet. Two examples of stored chemicals are Acetone and Potassium Cyanide. The Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) classified Acetone as EXTREMELY FLAMMABLE and the vapors of Acetone may cause a flash fire and are harmful if inhaled. The MSDS states, “…the Flash Point of Acetone is -4° F and should be handled under a vent hood with a proper ventilation system”. Potassium Cyanide is classified as EXTREME HEALTH HAZARD, POISON. MSDS states, “…Do not store near combustibles or flammables because subsequent fire fighting with water could lead to cyanide runoff. Do not store under sprinkler system”. Handling and storage for both chemicals should be in a cool, dry, well- ventilated location. The workroom where the chemicals are stored is maintained as an office space and is part of the buildings air conditioning system. 2
Related Recommendations (1)
R1
The Cooperative Extension Riverside County, Blythe store all chemicals in compliance with the appropriate MSDS.
F2
Improper Ventilation in the Cooperative Extension Area The County Administrative Center in Blythe is designed to be office space with gaps under the doors, and centralized air conditioning units that serve multiple areas. A drying oven is located in the lab. The heated air from the oven is ventilated into the lab area. The air conditioner for the lab area also controls the temperature in a nearby conference room and a small office. The thermostat for the air conditioner is located in this conference room. At the request of Cooperative Extension Riverside County, the Maintenance Department adjusted the controls for the air conditioner to maintain a temperature of 68° F. Office employees in nearby offices stated this resulted in “the conference room and office areas being unbearably cold”. The County Administrative Center building was designed and built in 1997 to accommodate various departments in an open concept. Board of Supervisors Policy H4 states, the Facilities Management Department will: “Set air conditioning and heating controls to comply with settings so as not to cool below 76° F, and not to heat above 68° F. Where a single temperature set point is, or where a system cools and heats simultaneously, the equipment will be operated in a manner that minimizes the use of electrical energy.” The different sections of the building all join through open spaces therefore anything that enters the air system in the lab will be circulated throughout the entire building. MSDS states a hood is required for the proper handling of most chemicals used by the lab personnel. However, there is no laboratory hood located within the lab area. The MSDS do not identify a quantity level of unsafe hazardous materials; therefore all volumes and quantities must be treated as hazardous. Riverside County Economic Development Agency, Facility Maintenance conducted an investigation into the ventilation of the lab area and wrote a report a section which is identified as “Plan B” dated May 3, 2011, which recommended necessary changes so the lab could become a self- contained unit. • “Remove all existing ductwork (supply and return air) from AC 301 to this area. • Install a new rooftop package unit and ductwork solely dedicated for the lab. Estimated cost $10,000.00. • Install an appropriately sized exhaust fan to adequately ensure a negative pressure room. Estimated cost $1,300.00.” 3
Related Recommendations (1)
R2
The Cooperative Extension Riverside County, Blythe remodel the lab as a self-contained unit by implementing “Plan B” of the Riverside County Economic Development Agency, Facility Maintenance Report dated May 3, 2011.
F3
No Hazardous Materials Handler Permit California Health and Safety Code Chapter 6.95 and Riverside County Ordinance 651 states, “…any regulated substance or Federal Extremely Hazardous Substance or California Acutely Hazardous Substance below five gallons requires a Hazard Materials Business Emergency Plan and a permit with the County of Riverside Community Health Agency, Department of Environmental Health.” At the time of this report, the Cooperative Extension has not submitted a Hazard Materials Business Emergency Plan to the proper authorities.
Related Recommendations (1)
R3
The Cooperative Extension Riverside County, Blythe create a Hazardous Materials Business Plan and obtain a Hazardous Materials Handlers Permit, as required by Safety Code Chapter 6.95 and Riverside County Ordinance 651.
F4
No Hazardous Materials Identification on Building In accordance with National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 704, (Exhibit #1) requirements for handling hazardous materials and California Health & Safety Code, Chapter 6.95, Section 25000-25520, requires that there should be identification on any building that stores or uses hazardous materials. This advises all persons and especially firefighters of the types of chemicals that are maintained within the building.
Related Recommendations (1)
R4
The Cooperative Extension Riverside County, Blythe place hazardous materials identification plaques on all entrances into the County Administration Center Building, Blythe in accordance with NFPA 704.
F5
No Hazardous Waste Generator Permit County of Riverside Hazardous Waste Generator form (HWG form dated 12/2005) identifies one type of waste as “Pesticide: Unusable portions of active pesticides, unrinsed empty containers, rinse water”. For example the MSDS for Potassium Cyanide states: “Dispose of container and unused contents in accordance with federal, state and local requirements”. The lab personnel stated the chemical containers were washed in water and rinsed 3 times. At the time of this investigation, there was no Hazardous Waste Generator Permit.
Related Recommendations (1)
R5
The Cooperative Extension Riverside County, Blythe obtain a Hazardous Waste Generator Permit, (HWG Form 12/2005).
F6
Improper Form Used for Hazardous Materials Inventory The inventory list of chemicals (Exhibit #2) is not recorded on the correct form required by the County of Riverside. The correct form is Office of Emergency Services (OES) Form 2731 (Exhibit #3). A separate form is required for each chemical and updated when a chemical is changed or moved. 4
Related Recommendations (1)
R6
The Cooperative Extension Riverside County, Blythe conform to Office of Emergency Services (OES) Form 2731 used for inventory of hazardous materials. Exhibit #1 6 Chemical Inventory List – UCCE Blythe CA laboratory Chemical name Active ingredient Amount (metric) Asana Esfenvalerate 473 ml Acetone Acetone 946 ml Actara Thiamethoxam 100 g Admire Flex 4 Imidacloprid 475 ml Admire Flex 4 Imidacloprid 475 ml Admire Flex 4 Imidacloprid 475 ml Admire Pro Imidacloprid 1 L Agri-Flex Thiamethoxam 75 ml Agri-mek Abamectin 50 ml Ammonia Ammonia 3.8 L Avaunt Indoxacarb 100 g Captan Captan 20 g Capture Bifenthrin 120 ml Coragen Chlorantraniliprole 946 ml Coragen Chlorantraniliprole 946 ml Coragen Chlorantraniliprole 946 ml Dipel Df Baccillus thuringiensis 454 g Durivo Thiamethoxam 500 ml Dyne Amic Methyl esters of fatty acids 200 ml Dyne Amic Methyl esters of fatty acids 200 ml Dyne Amic Methyl esters of fatty acids 200 ml Ethyl Acetate Ethyl Acetate 3.25 L Fluon Teflon 236 ml Fulfill Pymetrozine 50 g Fulfill Pymetrozine 100 g Histo Clear 2 Histo Clear 2 3.8 L Induce Alkyl aryl polyoxylkane ethers 200 ml Leverage Imidaclophid 475 ml Movento Spirotramat 475 ml Movento Spirotramat 475 ml Exhibit #2 7 Mustang Zeta cypermethrin 50 ml NN1-0101 20 SC Pyrifiuquinazon 200 ml NN1-0101 20 SC Pyrifiuquinazon 50 ml Oberon Spiromesifen 120 ml Oberon Spiromesifen 200 ml Permount Permount 100 ml Potassium Cyanide Potassium Cyanide 100 g Radiant Spinetoram 100 ml Scorpion Dinotefuran 100 ml Switch Cyprodinil 100 g Synapse Flubendiamide 50 g Synpse Flubendiamide 50 g Thionex Endosulfan 473 ml Thionex Endosulfan 473 ml Venom Dinotefuran 50 g Venom Dinotefuran 100 g Vetica Fluebendiamide 100 ml Vetica Fluebendiamide 1 L Voliam xpress Chlorantraniliprole 200 ml Voliam xpress Chlorantraniliprole 500 ml XenTari Baccillus thuringiensis 453.59 g Exhibit #2 8 Report Issued: 06/28/2011 Report Public: 06/30/2011 Response Due: 09/26/2011 9
No Responses Found 2
Government entities assigned to respond to this report. No response documents have been linked in our database.
Riverside County
County
Riverside County Coroner
Elected County Office