Trinity County Grand Jury • 2003-2004

Judicial Committee Final Report - Review of Public Defender*

Published: May 10, 2004 17 pages
View Original PDF

Findings and Recommendations 17 findings

F1
At the present time all attorneys working under the Public Defenders contract are residents of Trinity County, and are geographically accessible to their clients and client families. In the past some attorneys were hired from out of the area. This situation can cause undue hardship for all involved.
Related Recommendations (1)
R1
All future Public Defender contracts should attempt to retain the services of local attorneys, and future contracts should continue to require attorneys maintain a local office.
F2
The current contract makes provision for yearly attorney evaluations by the County Counsel, County Administrative Officer, and the Judges of the Superior Court, to ensure the performance requirements outlined in the contract are being met. The previous contract had the same provision without the inclusion of the judges, and evaluations have been conducted on an informal basis.
Related Recommendations (1)
R2
The attorney evaluations (as stated in the current agreement) should be conducted on a yearly basis with a resultant written report. These reports should be kept on file and made available to interested parties with legal justification for such access.
F3
Under the current system the only avenue a detainee has to contact their court appointed attorney is via a collect phone call from the jail. These calls are not reimbursable to the attorneys. Because of the outrageously high charges levied on these calls, both attorneys interviewed have adopted a policy of not accepting collect calls from their in-custody clients. The lack of communication requires the attorneys make a trip to the jail when a short telephone call would have sufficed.
Related Recommendations (1)
R3
Previously a local phone line existed in the jail for attorney contact. Funds from the Inmate Welfare Fund should be used to reestablish a dedicated phone line for inmate-attorney contact. If a direct line is not possible attorneys should be reimbursed for the calls from inmates. CONCLUSION: When compared to other counties statewide, Trinity County Public Defender per capita costs and caseload numbers seem reasonable. The Public Defenders and Courts appear to have a good working relationship and a history of cooperation. Clients interviewed were generally satisfied with their attorneys. Attorney performance is not easily evaluated in part because of client confidentiality, and the inclusion of Judicial oversight in the yearly evaluations provides firsthand knowledge of attorney performance to help ensure clients are receiving competent representation. -105- RESPONSES REQUIRED: RESPOND IN RECOMMENDATION ENTITY
F4
for the following services ("Call" or "Calls"): local, 4.1 The System will provide an automatic "on/off" interLATA, interstate, and/or international and/or feature. The System will have the capability of prepaid calling telephone services from inmate being monitored over a dedicated phone line to telephones at Client's designated facility(ies) as set provide for on-line diagnostics and troubleshooting. forth in Exhibit A attached hereto. During the term 4.2 The System will provide for automatic billing of this Agreement, T-NETIX shall be the exclusive and placing of collect calls without the need for provider of these services at Client's "Designated conventional live operator services. T-NETIX will be Facility" as shown on Exhibit "A". responsible for all billing and collections of inmate
Related Recommendations (1)
R4
for the following services ("Call" or "Calls"): local, 4.1 The System will provide an automatic "on/off" interLATA, interstate, and/or international and/or feature. The System will have the capability of prepaid calling telephone services from inmate being monitored over a dedicated phone line to telephones at Client's designated facility(ies) as set provide for on-line diagnostics and troubleshooting. forth in Exhibit A attached hereto. During the term 4.2 The System will provide for automatic billing of this Agreement, T-NETIX shall be the exclusive and placing of collect calls without the need for provider of these services at Client's "Designated conventional live operator services. T-NETIX will be Facility" as shown on Exhibit "A". responsible for all billing and collections of inmate
F5
2.2 Notwithstanding 2.1 above, this agreement 5.1 All components of the System including, but may be terminated by either party, and without not limited to, computer workstation(s), central further notice, if a party defaults in the performance processing unit(s), proprietary software and inmate of an obligation or materially breaches any of the telephones and concentrators provided by T-NETIX, terms or conditions of this agreement and fails to shall at all times remain the property of T-NETIX. cure such default or breach within thirty (30) days Data placed on the T-NETIX proprietary software by after service of written notice upon them of such Client shall remain the property of Client. default or breach. Notice of such default or breach shall be given as set forth in Paragraph 9.1. 5.2 The Parties agree that T-NETIX's software and T-NETIX Products and Services.
Related Recommendations (1)
R5
2.2 Notwithstanding 2.1 above, this agreement 5.1 All components of the System including, but may be terminated by either party, and without not limited to, computer workstation(s), central further notice, if a party defaults in the performance processing unit(s), proprietary software and inmate of an obligation or materially breaches any of the telephones and concentrators provided by T-NETIX, terms or conditions of this agreement and fails to shall at all times remain the property of T-NETIX. cure such default or breach within thirty (30) days Data placed on the T-NETIX proprietary software by after service of written notice upon them of such Client shall remain the property of Client. default or breach. Notice of such default or breach shall be given as set forth in Paragraph 9.1. 5.2 The Parties agree that T-NETIX's software and T-NETIX Products and Services.
F6
shall be in writing and addressed to Client at the 6.1 The System will have the capability to address in Section 8.2 above and to T-NETIX as automatically limit the duration of each Call to a follows: duration designated by T-NETIX and Client. If to T-NETIX: T-NETIX, Inc. Use of Space; Right of Access.
Related Recommendations (1)
R6
shall be in writing and addressed to Client at the 6.1 The System will have the capability to address in Section 8.2 above and to T-NETIX as automatically limit the duration of each Call to a follows: duration designated by T-NETIX and Client. If to T-NETIX: T-NETIX, Inc. Use of Space; Right of Access.
F7
Attention: President Client shall make available to T-NETIX 2155 Chenault Dr., Suite 410 7.1 sufficient space within the Designated Facilities for Carrollton, TX 75006 the System and to allow for T-NETIX's performance Telephone: (972) 236-1180 of services as required herein. The space should Fax: (972) 236-6977 have the appropriate heating, ventilation and air conditioning for the System. Prior to installation, T- with a copy to: T-NETIX, Inc. NETIX will provide Client with specifications for such Attention: Chief Legal Officer facilities and for the heating, ventilation and air 2155 Chenault Dr., Suite 410 conditioning. Telephone: (972) 236-1175 Fax: (972) 236-6978 7.2 Client shall afford T-NETIX personnel or contractors access to the System in order to or to such other address as either Party may perform services described herein. Reasonable designate from time-to-time in writing to the other security during access will be provided by Client. Party. Commissions. 8. 9.2 Unless otherwise provided herein, notices shall be sent by (i) hand delivery, (ii) registered or Subject to the provisions of this Section 8, 8.1 certified U.S. mail, postage prepaid, (iii) commercial T-NETIX will pay Client a commission of thirty-three courier delivery service, or (iv) facsimile, and shall (33%) of gross billed revenues (excluding federal, be deemed served or delivered (w) upon receipt at state and local fees, taxes and surcharges) from the address for notice specified above when hand completed Calls. Such fees, taxes and surcharges delivered, (x) upon confirmation of sending when include, but are not limited to, Federal Universal sent by facsimile, (y) when delivered after being Service Fund ("FUSF") amounts. In the event Client sent by courier delivery service, or (z) five (5) days authorizes prepaid calling services, T-NETIX may be after deposit in the mail when sent by U.S. mail. paid for such services through deductions from commissions.
Related Recommendations (1)
R7
Attention: President Client shall make available to T-NETIX 2155 Chenault Dr., Suite 410 7.1 sufficient space within the Designated Facilities for Carrollton, TX 75006 the System and to allow for T-NETIX's performance Telephone: (972) 236-1180 of services as required herein. The space should Fax: (972) 236-6977 have the appropriate heating, ventilation and air conditioning for the System. Prior to installation, T- with a copy to: T-NETIX, Inc. NETIX will provide Client with specifications for such Attention: Chief Legal Officer facilities and for the heating, ventilation and air 2155 Chenault Dr., Suite 410 conditioning. Telephone: (972) 236-1175 Fax: (972) 236-6978 7.2 Client shall afford T-NETIX personnel or contractors access to the System in order to or to such other address as either Party may perform services described herein. Reasonable designate from time-to-time in writing to the other security during access will be provided by Client. Party. Commissions.
F8
9.2 Unless otherwise provided herein, notices shall be sent by (i) hand delivery, (ii) registered or Subject to the provisions of this Section 8, 8.1 certified U.S. mail, postage prepaid, (iii) commercial T-NETIX will pay Client a commission of thirty-three courier delivery service, or (iv) facsimile, and shall (33%) of gross billed revenues (excluding federal, be deemed served or delivered (w) upon receipt at state and local fees, taxes and surcharges) from the address for notice specified above when hand completed Calls. Such fees, taxes and surcharges delivered, (x) upon confirmation of sending when include, but are not limited to, Federal Universal sent by facsimile, (y) when delivered after being Service Fund ("FUSF") amounts. In the event Client sent by courier delivery service, or (z) five (5) days authorizes prepaid calling services, T-NETIX may be after deposit in the mail when sent by U.S. mail. paid for such services through deductions from commissions.
Related Recommendations (1)
R8
9.2 Unless otherwise provided herein, notices shall be sent by (i) hand delivery, (ii) registered or Subject to the provisions of this Section 8, 8.1 certified U.S. mail, postage prepaid, (iii) commercial T-NETIX will pay Client a commission of thirty-three courier delivery service, or (iv) facsimile, and shall (33%) of gross billed revenues (excluding federal, be deemed served or delivered (w) upon receipt at state and local fees, taxes and surcharges) from the address for notice specified above when hand completed Calls. Such fees, taxes and surcharges delivered, (x) upon confirmation of sending when include, but are not limited to, Federal Universal sent by facsimile, (y) when delivered after being Service Fund ("FUSF") amounts. In the event Client sent by courier delivery service, or (z) five (5) days authorizes prepaid calling services, T-NETIX may be after deposit in the mail when sent by U.S. mail. paid for such services through deductions from commissions.
F9
circumstances of such required disclosure. 9.1 Unless otherwise provided herein, all notices and communications concerning this Agreement Call Duration.
Related Recommendations (1)
R9
circumstances of such required disclosure. 9.1 Unless otherwise provided herein, all notices and communications concerning this Agreement Call Duration.
F10
Indemnification. T-NETIX shall indemnify and hold Client harmless against all claims, 8.2 Separate commission payments shall be demands and causes of action made against Client payable on the 20th day of each month for the arising from damage to or destruction of property preceding month's call volume and shall be made or injury to persons occurring as a result of the acts payable to: or omissions of T-NETIX, its officers, employees, Client Name: subcontractors, or agents in furnishing or supplying Inmate Welfare Fund work, services, materials or supplies in connection Trinity County CA Sheriff's Department with the performance of this Agreement. In no 101 Memorial Drive event, however, will either Party be liable for Weaverville, CA 96093 punitive or consequential damages, even if Attn: Sheriff Lorrac Craig notification has been given as to the possibility of such damages, including but not limited to, loss of causes of nonperformance and will continue its business interruption, profits, telephone or performance whenever and to the extent such howsoever caused and even if due to the causes are removed. negligence, breach of contract or other fault of the respective Parties.
Related Recommendations (1)
R10
Indemnification. T-NETIX shall indemnify and hold Client harmless against all claims, 8.2 Separate commission payments shall be demands and causes of action made against Client payable on the 20th day of each month for the arising from damage to or destruction of property preceding month's call volume and shall be made or injury to persons occurring as a result of the acts payable to: or omissions of T-NETIX, its officers, employees, Client Name: subcontractors, or agents in furnishing or supplying Inmate Welfare Fund work, services, materials or supplies in connection Trinity County CA Sheriff's Department with the performance of this Agreement. In no 101 Memorial Drive event, however, will either Party be liable for Weaverville, CA 96093 punitive or consequential damages, even if Attn: Sheriff Lorrac Craig notification has been given as to the possibility of such damages, including but not limited to, loss of causes of nonperformance and will continue its business interruption, profits, telephone or performance whenever and to the extent such howsoever caused and even if due to the causes are removed. negligence, breach of contract or other fault of the respective Parties.
F11
General. be or for one year thereafter shall have any interest, interpreted, construed and enforced pursuant to the direct or indirect, in this Agreement or the proceeds laws of the State of California. If any term, covenant or condition contained herein shall be thereof. invalid or unenforceable to any extent and in any respect under any laws governing this Agreement, Worker's Compensation. T-NETIX
Related Recommendations (1)
R11
General. be or for one year thereafter shall have any interest, interpreted, construed and enforced pursuant to the direct or indirect, in this Agreement or the proceeds laws of the State of California. If any term, covenant or condition contained herein shall be thereof. invalid or unenforceable to any extent and in any respect under any laws governing this Agreement, Worker's Compensation. T-NETIX
F12
Force Majeure. Neither Party will be liable to the other for delays or inability to perform their
Related Recommendations (1)
R12
Force Majeure. Neither Party will be liable to the other for delays or inability to perform their
F13
Interest of Public Officials. No officer, agent or employee of the Client during their tenure This Agreement shall
Related Recommendations (1)
R13
Interest of Public Officials. No officer, agent or employee of the Client during their tenure This Agreement shall
F14
acknowledges that it is aware of the provisions of the remainder of this Agreement shall not be the Labor Code of the State of California which affected thereby, and each term, covenant or condition of this Agreement shall be valid and requires every employer to be insured against liability for worker's compensation or to undertake enforceable to the fullest extent permitted by applicable law. This Agreement shall not be binding self-insurance in accordance with the provisions of upon either Party until accepted in writing by an that Code and it certifies that it will comply with authorized representative of T-NETIX as indicated provisions commencing such before the by the signature below. This Agreement may not be performance of the work of this Agreement. A copy assigned or transferred to any other person or of the certificates evidencing such insurance shall entity without the prior written mutual agreement of be provided to Client prior to commencement of the Parties. Should T-NETIX assign this Agreement work. to any person acquiring all or substantially all of its assets or to any person or entity with or into which This Agreement is to be performed by employees subject to these provisions. A copy of the relevant T-NETIX merges, Client may, at its option, prevailing wage is on file with the Department of terminate the agreement effective as of the date Transportation, County of Trinity, PO Box 2490, such assignment occurs. Should Client not exercise Weaverville, California 96093. Copies will be its option to terminate and desire to continue receiving the services provided pursuant to this provided upon request. Agreement, it is understood and agreed, that all terms and conditions hereof will be binding upon Nondiscriminatory Employment.
Related Recommendations (1)
R14
acknowledges that it is aware of the provisions of the remainder of this Agreement shall not be the Labor Code of the State of California which
F15
In and inure to the assignee or merged surviving entity connection with the execution of thisAgreement, T- as though such entity was an original party to this NETIX shall not discriminate against any employee Agreement. This provision shall be included in the or applicant for employment because of race, color, document memorializing the transferring of T- religion, age, sex, national original, political NETIX's assets to such assignee or merged affiliation, ancestry, marital status, disability or surviving entity. sexual orientation. This policy does not require the employment of unqualified persons.
Related Recommendations (1)
R15
In and inure to the assignee or merged surviving entity connection with the execution of thisAgreement, T- as though such entity was an original party to this NETIX shall not discriminate against any employee Agreement. This provision shall be included in the or applicant for employment because of race, color, document memorializing the transferring of T- religion, age, sex, national original, political NETIX's assets to such assignee or merged affiliation, ancestry, marital status, disability or surviving entity. sexual orientation. This policy does not require the employment of unqualified persons.
F16
Entire Agreement; Amendments. This obligations if such failure results from a Force Agreement represents the entire Agreement Majeure event, which will include any Acts of God, between the Parties with respect to the matters acts of governments, acts of terrorism, riots, wars, addressed herein and supersedes all prior strikes, fires, weather, delays in transportation, negotiations, representations or agreements shortages of materials, the unavailability of between the Parties, whether written or oral, on equipment or other matters beyond the reasonable the subject matter hereof. This Agreement may control of the Party. Any such Force Majeure event not be amended, modified, altered, or rescinded will extend the time for such performance for a except upon a written instrument designated as an period equal to the period of delay; provided amendment to this Agreement and executed by all however, that the Party whose performance is Parties hereto. prevented or delayed by such Force Majeure will take all reasonable steps to avoid or remove such
Related Recommendations (1)
R16
Entire Agreement; Amendments. This obligations if such failure results from a Force Agreement represents the entire Agreement Majeure event, which will include any Acts of God, between the Parties with respect to the matters acts of governments, acts of terrorism, riots, wars, addressed herein and supersedes all prior strikes, fires, weather, delays in transportation, negotiations, representations or agreements shortages of materials, the unavailability of between the Parties, whether written or oral, on equipment or other matters beyond the reasonable the subject matter hereof. This Agreement may control of the Party. Any such Force Majeure event not be amended, modified, altered, or rescinded will extend the time for such performance for a except upon a written instrument designated as an period equal to the period of delay; provided amendment to this Agreement and executed by all however, that the Party whose performance is Parties hereto. prevented or delayed by such Force Majeure will take all reasonable steps to avoid or remove such
F17
Exhibits. This Agreement includes Exhibits Exhibit A, Facilities; and attached hereto as indicated below: T-NETIX Proposal Dated May 14, 2004. T-NETIX, Inc. CLIENT Signature: COUNTY OF TRINITY Printed Name: Thomas R Merriam By: EVP - Strategic Markets Title: Chair, Board-of-Directors_ Robert A. Reiss, Chairman of the Board ATTEST: Clerk APPROVED AS TO By:_ FORM INITIAL DATE Deputy CC 7.13.0 AUD APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORM CAO Fund: Organization: Account: County Auditor Counsel By: Title: THE SYSTEM INSTALLED AT THE SITE MAY HAVE THE CAPACITY TO RECORD INMATE PHONE CALLS AND/OR ALLOW CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS TO MONITOR INMATE PHONE CALLS. BY PROVIDING EQUIPMENT HAVING EITHER OR BOTH OF THESE CAPABILITIES, T-NETIX MAKES NO REPRESENTATIONS AS TO THE LEGALITY OF RECORDING OR MONITORING INMATE TELEPHONE CALLS. EXHIBIT A Trinity County Sheriff's Office Facility Name & Address: 1. Memorial Drive Weaverville, CA 96093 Trinity County Juvenile Probation Department 333 Tom Bell Road Weaverville, CA 96093 (ATTACHMENTS NOT INCLUDED - SEE ORIGINAL COUNTY CONTRACT) RECEIVEDSEP 1 0 2004 TRINITY COUNTY UPERIOR RINITY COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS P.O. BOX 1613, WEAVERVILLE, CALIFORNIA 96093 PHONE (530) 623-1217 FAX (530) 623-8365 /gP ijķ, TO: Honorable Anthony Edwards Trinity County Board of Supervisors FROM: Response to 2003-04 Trinity County Grand Jury Judicial Committee SUBJECT: Final Report. "Review of Public Defenders". DATE: Sept. 7, 2004 The Trinity County Grand Jury has requested a written response to the Judicial Committee's final report regarding "Review of Public Defenders". Finding #1: At the present time all attorneys working under the Public Defenders contract are residents of Trinity County, and are geographically accessible to their clients and clients families. In the past some attorneys were hired from out of the area. This situation can cause hardship for all involved.
Related Recommendations (1)
R17
Exhibits. This Agreement includes Exhibits Exhibit A, Facilities; and attached hereto as indicated below: T-NETIX Proposal Dated May 14, 2004. T-NETIX, Inc. CLIENT Signature: COUNTY OF TRINITY Printed Name: Thomas R Merriam By: EVP - Strategic Markets Title: Chair, Board-of-Directors_ Robert A. Reiss, Chairman of the Board ATTEST: Clerk APPROVED AS TO By:_ FORM INITIAL DATE Deputy CC 7.13.0 AUD APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORM CAO Fund: Organization: Account: County Auditor Counsel By: Title: THE SYSTEM INSTALLED AT THE SITE MAY HAVE THE CAPACITY TO RECORD INMATE PHONE CALLS AND/OR ALLOW CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS TO MONITOR INMATE PHONE CALLS. BY PROVIDING EQUIPMENT HAVING EITHER OR BOTH OF THESE CAPABILITIES, T-NETIX MAKES NO REPRESENTATIONS AS TO THE LEGALITY OF RECORDING OR MONITORING INMATE TELEPHONE CALLS. EXHIBIT A Trinity County Sheriff's Office Facility Name & Address:

Conclusions 13

No Responses Found 3

Government entities assigned to respond to this report. No response documents have been linked in our database.

Trinity County County
Trinity County Board of Supervisors Elected County Office
Trinity County Sheriff Elected County Office

* This report's PDF did not contain easily extractable text and required Optical Character Recognition (OCR) for analysis. There may be minor errors in the extracted findings and recommendations due to OCR limitations with scanned documents.