📋
Extracted from Consolidated Report
This investigation was originally published as part of a larger consolidated report containing multiple investigations. View the consolidated PDF for the complete document.
⚠️ Translation Notice: This content has been automatically translated. The original English text is the official version. Translation may contain errors.
⚠️ Este contenido ha sido traducido automáticamente. El texto original en inglés es la versión oficial. La traducción puede contener errores.
Findings 10 findings
F1
Page 17
Pursuant to Yuba County Policy and Procedures Manual, the Board of Supervisors is the only County entity that is authorized to establish, change and waive fees for County- provided services.
F2
Page 17
“Half fee” waivers were given to residential construction projects, where the work was performed by the owners themselves, between 2005 and 2008, without authority from the Board of Supervisors.
F3
Page 17
“Half fee” waivers were given to a commercial home developer group in October 2006.
F4
Page 17
“Half fee” waivers were given to a commercial construction project in May 2008, which was and is owned by a former Yuba County Supervisor.
F5
Page 17
A similar commercial construction project to that of the former Supervisor did not receive the “half fee” waiver in May 2008, but rather paid full price.
F6
Page 17
The Chief Building Official did not and does not have the authority to establish, change and waive permit fees.
F7
Page 17
The Chief Building Official appears to have exhibited favoritism by providing the “half fee” waiver to residential construction projects, where the work was performed by the owners themselves.
F8
Page 17
The Chief Building Official appears to have exhibited favoritism by granting the “half fee” waiver to one commercial home developer group.
F9
Page 17
The Chief Building Official appears to have exhibited favoritism by granting the “half fee” waiver to a former Supervisor for his commercial construction project, while not granting the “half fee” waiver to a similar commercial construction project taking place during the same timeframe.
F10
Page 17
The Chief Building Official stated he was instructed by the Board of Supervisors to provide the “half fee” waiver, but the Supervisors who were interviewed had no knowledge of such a waiver.
Recommendations 4
-
R1Page 17Increased oversight should be implemented to ensure that only fees authorized by the Board of Supervisors are charged.
-
R2Page 17The Chief Building Official should be held accountable for failing to follow the County’s Administrative Policy & Procedures Manual, Policy B-2, regarding the establishment of fees.
-
R3Page 17The Chief Building Official should be held accountable for a perceived show of favoritism when providing the “half fee” to residential construction projects where the work is 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Unauthorized Changes in Building Permit Fees performed by the owners themselves, as well as to the two commercial construction projects.
-
R4Page 18The Chief Building Official should be held accountable for the loss of revenue to the Building Department.
Commendations 1
-
CM1The Grand Jury commends the County of Yuba Office of Emergency Services Manager and County Administrative Officer for making the most of limited time, staff and resources to develop a center that is organized, professional, and user friendly. The Emergency Operations Manager has gleaned a well-established team of knowledgeable professionals who are trained and familiar with the OES Operations Center. The Manager is also to be commended for his continuing efforts to coordinate emergency management teams from public safety and service providers, making OES an organization capable of coordinating responders during any emergency. The Grand Jury commends the City of Wheatland for working closely with the OES. The police department’s plan to include an OES Operations Center in its new facility reflects the city’s attitude of cooperation and unity in working with Yuba County OES. The Grand Jury commends the Yuba County Sheriff and his department for fulfilling NIMS training requirements and participating in OES training events, as well as cooperating with OES by participating in its management team to ensure the County is ready to provide coordinated disaster or emergency response. REQUEST FOR RESPONSES Pursuant to Penal code section 933.05, the grand jury requests responses as follows: From the following individuals: County of Yuba, Emergency Operations Manager F7, R3 City of Marysville, Chief of Police F3, F5-7, R1-3 City of Marysville, Mayor F3, F5-7, R1-3 BIBLIOGRAPHY Reports issued by the Civil Grand Jury do not identify individuals interviewed. Penal Code Section 929 requires that reports of the Grand Jury not contain the name of any person or facts leading to the identity of any person who provides information to the Civil Grand Jury. This report “History of Flood and Flames: Emergency Preparedness of Yuba County” is issued by the 2011-2012 Grand Jury with the exception of one member of this Grand Jury. This Grand Juror was excluded from all parts of the investigation, which included interviews, deliberations, and the making and acceptance of the report. This report is based on information obtained from outside sources with none of the information being obtained from the excluded Grand Juror. 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 43 of 96 History of Flood and Flames APPENDIX A CITY OF MARYSVILLE EMPLOYEE FEMA COMPLIANCE NOVEMBER 16, 2010 (Provided to the Grand Jury by the Emergency Operations Manager) THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN REDACTED 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 44 of 96 History of Flood and Flames 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 45 of 96 History of Flood and Flames APPENDIX B LETTER FROM THE FOREPERSON OF THE YUBA COUNTY GRAND JURY TO THE CITY OF MARYSVILLE REQUESTING A COPY OF THE MARYSVILLE EMERGENCY ACTION PLAN (Provided by the 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury) 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 46 of 96 History of Flood and Flames 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 47 of 96 History of Flood and Flames APPENDIX C LETTER FROM THE CITY OF MARYSVILLE CHIEF OF POLICE TO EMERGENCY OPERATIONS MANAGER OF YUBA COUNTY REQUESTING YUBA COUNTY OES ASSISTANCE IN COMPLETING NIMS REQUIRED TRAINING (Provided by Emergency Operations Manager) 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 48 of 96 History of Flood and Flames 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 49 of 96 History of Flood and Flames APPENDIX D LETTER OF RESPONSE FROM EMERGENCY OPERATIONS MANAGER TO THE CITY OF MARYSVILLE CHIEF OF POLICE (APPENDIX C) (Provided by Emergency Operations Manager) THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN REDACTED 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 50 of 96 History of Flood and Flames 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 51 of 96 History of Flood and Flames 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 52 of 96 Oh Say Can You See…? Oh Say Can You See…?: (The Star Spangled Banner by Francis Scott Keyes) The City Of Marysville’s Display of the U.S. Flag “What’s this?” Similar to an old-fashioned bar code, a QR (which stands for "quick response") code is a black and white graphic box holding valuable information. Download any QR Reader for your smart phone and scan the above symbol to take you to the complete electronic version of this report. QR Reader programs are available for no charge and make information easily available to access and read. These codes will be found throughout the Grand Jury reports to take you to the full electronic version of the report, the Yuba County Grand Jury home page, or other valuable information. 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 53 of 96 Oh Say Can You See…? This page intentionally left blank 2011-2012 Yuba County Grand Jury Final Report Page 54 of 96 Oh Say Can You See…? “Oh, Say Can You See…?” (The Star Spangled Banner by Francis Scott Keyes) THE CITY OF MARYSVILLE’S DISPLAY OF THE U.S. FLAG SUMMARY Many people visit D Street, the City of Marysville’s “main” street. Like many small towns in America, it has that Main Street U.S.A. look and appeal. The City of Marysville has made every effort to make the business district inviting for visitors and shoppers. To enhance this Main Street look, the City installed decorative arches over the intersections along D Street between 3rd and 6th Streets. Atop each of the arches, the City flies the flag of the United States. While the flags are visible in the noon-day sun, the same cannot be said when the sun goes down. The flags are not illuminated at night, although the lighting system appears to be in place. This is contrary to Title 4, United States Code.
No Responses Found 1
Government entities assigned to respond to this report. No response documents have been linked in our database.
Yuba County
County