Score: +3
(6/13/3)
Butte County Grand Jury
• 2024-2025
Grand Jury Report Fiscal Year 2024-2025
⚠️ Translation Notice: This content has been automatically translated. The original English text is the official version. Translation may contain errors.
⚠️ Este contenido ha sido traducido automáticamente. El texto original en inglés es la versión oficial. La traducción puede contener errores.
Findings 7 findings
F1
Expenditures proceeded without budgeted line items, proper documentation, or council approval.
F2
Tenants occupied the Industrial Park without current, valid lease agreements.
F3
Flooding causes septic failures and contamination of coliform bacteria and high nitrates in stormwater, generating a continuous health hazard.
F4
Many citizens are unaware of the Butte County Connect website (or its replacement), to report issues to the County that can be traced by logs.
F5
There has not been prompt, targeted communication to citizens about the status of stalled projects.
F6
Wyandotte Basin GSA must sponsor and collaborate on projects addressing dry wells and water quality as mandated by SB 552
F7
Neglect and delays in execution of solutions have caused Palermo citizens disbelief and despair.
Recommendations 9
-
R1- The Grand Jury recommends that the City Council of Biggs complete a comprehensive fiscal audit of the Biggs Industrial Park by January 1, 2026. The City Council should initiate an independent fiscal audit reviewing all expenditures, labor allocations, and vendor relationships related to the Industrial Park, including but not limited to: • Complete financial reconstruction of all Industrial Park expenditures from July 2023 to present • Analysis of authorization processes for each transaction • Verification of work performed against payments made • Documentation of all materials and labor provided by city staff
-
R2- The Grand Jury recommends that the City of Biggs establish and maintain accurate financial records for the Industrial Park operations by December 1, 2025. The City should implement a system where public records of Industrial Park financial activities are maintained and updated on a monthly basis, including all revenues, expenditures, and outstanding obligations.
-
R3- The Grand Jury recommends that the City of Biggs complete lease standardization and legal review for all Industrial Park tenancies by December 1, 2025. All new and existing leases must be standardized, legally vetted, and approved in open session before new or continued tenant occupancy/operations, including but not limited to: • Market-based rate structure with transparent justification • Standardized insurance and liability requirements • Establishment of formal tenant recruitment and approval process • Consistent terms and conditions across all leases • Defined process for lease review and renewal A public registry of all city leases should be created and maintained by city administrators and made available to the public for review. 18
-
R4- The Grand Jury recommends that the City of Biggs execute current, legally compliant lease agreements for all Industrial Park tenants by January 31, 2026. Valid lease agreements must be in place for all existing tenants, with no exceptions for verbal agreements or expired contracts.
-
R5The Grand Jury recommends that LOAPUD extend sewer services to Palermo
-
R6The Grand Jury recommends that Butte County Administration utilize Facebook, public noticeboards at USPS, flyers at public gatherings to remind Butte County citizens that they should report issues via County Connect website, or its replacement, to log requests for work that must be expedited by December 31, 2025. 30
-
R7The Grand Jury recommends that the District 1 Supervisor, Public Works director, Water & Resource Conservation Director, Environmental Health Director, and 3 Palermo citizen representatives (including a Palermo Community Council member) meet quarterly as a Palermo Task Force formed by October 2025 for a minimum of 3 years.
-
R8Butte County 2026 120,000/year
-
R9Board of Supervisors By May 31, 2027 Staff time APPENDIX: PRIORITY DRAINAGE CLEANUP PLAN Required Action: Remove all cattails and vegetation on ditch banks and bottoms (as in 7059 Perkins Avenue) Resource Estimates: a crew of 8 from Public Works could clear approximately 10,000 feet of drainage ditch with light vegetation in 2 days. Heavy vegetation will slow progress. But the use of specialized equipment like the Rotary Ditch Cleaner GR70 or similar would significantly expedite ditch cleanup work. Summer 2025 Priority Sections (estimated lengths) 1. High Priority (800 feet) -- Perkins Ave to Palermo Ave 2. Critical Flow Path (1,300 feet) -- South Villa to Railroad Ave 3. Main Drainage (1,300 feet) -- Railroad Ave to Wyman Tributary 4. Critical Intersection Clearance of Perkins-- 20 ft upstream/downstream at: a. Palermo Rd b. Kenilworth Rd c. Williams Rd d. Ludlum Rd 46 47 Palermo is Ready to Have Their Pool Back Feather River Recreation and Parks District to the Rescue!
Conclusions 2
-
CL1 Page 30All Palermo Projects have suffered delays or neglect, causing citizens' despair and disbelief. There is no process nor is there any targeted communication to the citizens on the issues and status of the projects, or whether milestones were met. Jurors are also aware that these projects take years from planning, to funding, to execution, beyond the term of our Grand Jury. So, we, the Grand Jury, believe that many agencies and departments need to coordinate efforts to provide solutions to the issues Palermo residents face including flooding, clean water, dry wells and septic failure. The immediate formation of a task force with representative members from those agencies and community members may aid in achieving a solution without further delay.
-
CL2 Page 55The Grand Jury wishes to commend FRRPD for their diligent efforts and time conscious push to complete the Palermo Pool renovation and in turn serve the citizens of Palermo. Responsible parties are committed to making a difference in the community by following through on promised projects, and FRRPD is doing just that. The people of Palermo are wishing for a 'Grand Reopening Celebration' of their pool, and hope that it is this summer!
Agency Responses 2
Government agencies' official responses to this report's findings and recommendations. Click on a response to see the structured breakdown.